取材自FB

芥菜,真的是我以前超抗拒的菜,特別是過年必吃的長年菜,我連筷子都不想伸過去!但最近,我居然開始常喝芥菜湯,原因還挺有意思。

話說很多年前,媽媽感冒得很嚴重,有次在市場邊走邊狂咳,咳到呼吸不過來。這時一位阿姨熱心跑來教她:「回家用芥菜加地瓜煮湯,喝幾次就好了!」媽媽半信半疑,但回去試了,結果真的好了!從那之後,這偏方就變成我們家的標配,誰感冒她就煮這湯,還挺管用。

最近感冒的人很多,媽媽又叮囑我:「這湯多跟人推薦,天然ㄟ尚好!」

不加糖、鹽巴 喝原汁原味的菜湯
Past 31 days
Total Visit: 0
There are 5 fact-checking replies to the message
Huaisen Sabedoria mark this message contains misinformation
originally written by Huaisen Sabedoria
芥菜地瓜湯並沒有治感冒的效果。

References

https://youtu.be/vy2LqT_YJi0

印尼大象救起被山洪沖走的老虎?台鐵新規定 65 歲以上搭車半票?台大線上減重門診加 LINE 就能看?中共公開器官移植順序?|MyGoPen 謠言週報 #70

【 上週熱傳!謠言排行榜 Top 5 你有看過嗎?⚠️】【 各段重點 】00:00 開頭01:00 5️⃣ 中共公開器官移植制度,順序是依照官員職等分配?02:45 4️⃣ 台大線上減重門診廣告,只要加 LINE 就能取得調理方案?04:24 3️⃣ 印尼蘇門答臘發生山洪,大象救起被沖走的老虎?06:09 2️⃣...

https://youtu.be/vy2LqT_YJi0
Lin mark this message contains misinformation
originally written by Lin
芥菜煲番薯薑湯,坊間說有治風寒感冒之效。但要注意這只是偏方,感冒時的飲食原則應符合以下幾點:濃度高易獲得營養素(例如濃湯類)、高蛋白質強化身體自癒力和減少消化負擔的流質食物。食物本身沒有療效。

References

https://www.ftvnews.com.tw/news/detail/2024C16W0207
https://www.commonhealth.com.tw/article/89496
Alexios M mark this message contains personal perspective
originally written by Alexios M
This is a personal opinion about mustard soup helping people deal with a cold. There is some evidence that mustard greens help immune system but it's hard to generalize and overall the message doesn't really do any harm other than encouraging people to eat vegetables.

Opinion Sources

https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/mustard-greens-nutrition#:~:text=Mustard greens may also be,for a strong immune system.
陳竑齊 mark this message contains personal perspective
originally written by 陳竑齊
這篇文章是各社群平台都有在轉傳的文章,芥菜的各種偏方與說法一直以來就有很多,像是能補腎、能止咳,加地瓜煮湯可以治感冒等等。第一:芥菜確實含維生素C、鉀與一些礦物質,喝熱湯時的暖意也能稍微舒緩喉嚨,但這並不等於它能治療咳嗽或感冒,很多人喝了覺得有效,往往是因為熱湯本來就能讓痰比較好排出,身體在休息幾天後也會自然復原,因此若把它寄望成治病或補腎的靈丹就有點誇大了。

Opinion Sources

https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1A66gteWod/
https://www.threads.com/@xiaoying8107/post/DF7BmsMsyjO?hl=zh-tw

Threads 上的許小英(@xiaoying8107)

芥菜、俗稱年夜菜. 你可知道它的妙用在那裡? 芥菜,真的是我以前超抗拒的菜,特別是過年必吃的長年菜,我連筷子都不想伸過去!但最近,我居然開始常喝芥菜湯,原因還挺有意思。...

https://www.threads.com/@xiaoying8107/post/DF7BmsMsyjO?hl=zh-tw
Renee Green mark this message contains true information
originally written by Renee Green
芥菜與地瓜煮湯在傳統中被認為具有一定的滋補作用,但其對於咳嗽的療效尚缺乏科學證據支持。建議在使用前諮詢專業醫療人員,以確保安全與適合個人狀況。

References

https://fymission.cc/芥菜加地瓜煮湯可以治咳嗽嗎?/

The content above by Cofacts message reporting chatbot and crowd-sourced fact-checking community is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 (CC BY-SA 4.0), the community name and the provenance link for each item shall be fully cited for further reproduction or redistribution.

Automated analysis from AI
Add Cofacts as friend in LINE
Add Cofacts as friend in LINE
LINE 機器人
查謠言詐騙